Jimmy Joy Plenny Shake vs ComFoo
Plenny Shake or a Swedish alternative?
Three recipes. The same declared energy. Different ways to choose.
Compare Jimmy Joy Plenny Shake Vanilla with ComFoo Original and Sport Chocolate. Start with the ingredients, then look at what your order will cost.

Try something tasty from ComFoo.
A little help to try something new. Choose a flavour you are curious about and get a personal welcome voucher.
10 € on your first purchase
Personal voucher in your account. Applies to goods, not shipping. See terms.
A Swedish alternative to Jimmy Joy Plenny Shake
Have you found Plenny Shake from Jimmy Joy and want to compare it with a Swedish alternative? ComFoo Original and Sport are two meal powders worth a closer look. All three recipes here list 400 kcal per serving, but their ingredients, serving weights and purchase options differ.
We compare Plenny Shake Vanilla v4.0 with ComFoo Original Chocolate and Sport Chocolate. Vanilla and chocolate are different flavours, so the table cannot tell you which one you will prefer.
This article is written by ComFoo. It is based on product labels and dated online prices, not an independent taste test. See sources and scope.



Which Plenny Shake are we comparing?
Jimmy Joy is the brand and Plenny Shake is the product range. Here we mean Vanilla v4.0, not Plenny Shake Pro, bars or ready-to-drink meals.
| Product | Flavour and version | Powder per serving | Energy |
|---|---|---|---|
| Jimmy Joy Plenny Shake | Vanilla v4.0 | 96 g | 400 kcal |
| ComFoo Original | Chocolate | 99 g | 400 kcal |
| ComFoo Sport | Chocolate | 98 g | 400 kcal |
Follow the serving weight on the bag when switching products. The same number of scoops does not necessarily give you the same amount of powder.
What does each serving provide?
| Nutrient | Plenny Vanilla v4.0 · 96 g | Original Chocolate · 99 g | Sport Chocolate · 98 g |
|---|---|---|---|
| Energy | 400 kcal | 400 kcal | 400 kcal |
| Protein | 25 g | 21.8 g | 29.3 g |
| Carbohydrates | 38 g | 52.2 g | 39.6 g |
| Fat | 15 g | 10 g | 10.8 g |
| Fibre | 7.6 g | 6 g | 8.1 g |
Sport has more protein and fibre than Plenny in these specific servings. Original has more carbohydrates, while Plenny has more fat than either ComFoo recipe. These are differences in composition, not ratings of meal quality.
ComFoo's Chocolate labels were reviewed on 15 October 2026. Jimmy Joy's Vanilla v4.0 declaration was checked on 20 October 2026. The values refer to the powder. Milk or another drink adds its own nutrients.
Oats in all three, but different ingredient bases
| Recipe | Selected ingredients | Sweetening | Labelling to check |
|---|---|---|---|
| Plenny Vanilla v4.0 | Oats, soy, soy protein isolate, sunflower oil, rice flour, flaxseed and inulin. | Sucralose. | Oats and soy. Jimmy Joy states that Plenny Shake is not suitable for a gluten-free diet. |
| Original Chocolate | Oats, maltodextrin from maize, pea protein, rapeseed oil and cocoa. | Sucralose. | Oats. Original is not ComFoo’s gluten-free range. |
| Sport Chocolate | Gluten-free oats, pea protein, oat protein, fava bean flour, rapeseed oil and cocoa. | Sucralose. | Contains oats. Read all allergen and trace warnings on the packaging. |
This is a selection of ingredients, not the full list. Always check the flavour and packaging you will use, especially if you have an allergy.
Curious to try it?
The tables help you compare. Then comes the fun part: finding your own favourite.
10 € on your first purchase
Personal voucher in your account. Applies to goods, not shipping. See terms.
What does Plenny Shake cost in Sweden?
Jimmy Joy's EU shop displays prices in euros. Here is a dated price reference for Vanilla with ten servings per bag, excluding delivery.
| Purchase option | Per bag | Per serving |
|---|---|---|
| One-off purchase | 21.90 EUR | 2.19 EUR |
| Subscription with a 20% discount | 17.52 EUR | 1.75 EUR |
The page also shows limited-time promotions. Check the current price, shipping charge and delivery to Sweden at checkout. Your total in SEK depends on the exchange rate and any currency conversion fees.
The price per serving is the bag price divided by ten and rounded to two decimal places. No exchange rate has been assumed. The table is a price reference, not a promise of your order total.
ComFoo's Swedish price references
| Product | Servings per bag | One-off purchase | Subscription |
|---|---|---|---|
| Original Chocolate | 20 | 569 SEK per bag 28.45 SEK per serving | 483.65 SEK per bag 24.18 SEK per serving |
| Sport Chocolate | 16 | 409 SEK per bag 25.56 SEK per serving | 347.65 SEK per bag 21.73 SEK per serving |
Sport is shown at the promotional price of 409 SEK; its regular price is 509 SEK. Subscription prices include a 15 % discount on the current bag price. The number of servings per bag is a separate product detail from the serving weight on the nutrition label. Prices and stock may change.
Compare the whole order in the same currency: number of bags, chosen purchase option, delivery and any fees. A lower price per serving does not necessarily mean a lower total for your first purchase.
Jimmy Joy's subscription and membership are different things
| Option | What it means | Check |
|---|---|---|
| One-off purchase | You buy the order you have selected. | The current price and delivery charge for the whole order. |
| Product subscription | Recurring deliveries with the displayed subscription discount. | Jimmy Joy states that changes must be made at least 48 hours before the next order is dispatched. |
| Plenny Club | A separate membership costing 39 EUR per year, with no automatic renewal according to the terms. | 10 % cashback is awarded as store credit. The credit can be used for one-off purchases, not subscription products. |
We have not deducted membership credit from the price per serving. The membership has its own cost and terms of use. Also check which price applies to your next delivery once a promotion ends.
If you want to try ComFoo after Plenny Shake
| What you are looking for | Take a closer look at | Keep in mind |
|---|---|---|
| A Swedish alternative | ComFoo Original and Sport. | The ranges have different recipes. Choose according to ingredients and flavour preferences. |
| More protein per 400 kcal | Sport Chocolate: 29.3 g compared with Plenny Vanilla v4.0: 25 g. | The comparison applies to these specific servings. |
| A different ingredient base | Plenny's soy and sunflower oil compared with ComFoo's pea protein and rapeseed oil. | Read the full ingredients list and allergen labelling. |
| A flavour you enjoy | A flavour you already tend to enjoy. | Vanilla and chocolate taste different. Follow the mixing instructions on each bag. |
If you want to include Huel, there is a separate comparison of ComFoo, Huel and Jimmy Joy. Here we focus on Plenny and the two ComFoo recipes.
Frequently asked questions about Plenny Shake and ComFoo
What is Jimmy Joy Plenny Shake?
It is a meal powder mixed with water. Vanilla v4.0 in this comparison lists 400 kcal and 25 g of protein per 96 g of powder. Other Plenny products and flavours may have different values.
Is there a Swedish alternative to Plenny Shake?
Yes. ComFoo Original and Sport are two options if you want to compare meal powders from a Swedish brand. Here we compare the Chocolate recipes with Plenny Vanilla v4.0, using the same declared energy per serving.
Where can I order Jimmy Joy for delivery to Sweden?
You can check the current range and delivery to Sweden in Jimmy Joy's own EU shop. We sell ComFoo on this website. Check delivery costs and the final price before confirming a purchase.
Is Plenny Shake gluten-free?
Jimmy Joy states that Plenny Shake is not suitable for a gluten-free diet. The Vanilla recipe contains oats and soy. Check the labelling on your bag. ComFoo Original and Sport also differ in ingredients and labelling.
Is ComFoo cheaper than Plenny Shake?
You cannot determine this by comparing an amount in euros directly with Swedish kronor. Compare the same purchase option and the actual order total in the same currency, including delivery and any currency conversion fees.
Your welcome voucher, simply explained.
| Your question… | How it works |
|---|---|
| What does the discount apply to? | Goods across your whole first order. No minimum order amount. Shipping is not discounted. |
| Can I share it? | No. It is tied to your account, your email address and the currency it is issued in. |
| How do I get it? | Confirm your email address and choose a password using the email link, or continue with your verified Google account. |
| How do I use it? | Select Use under Your vouchers at checkout. Check the total before placing your order. |
| What if I subscribe? | The voucher applies to the first delivery. The regular subscription discount on meals is unaffected. The voucher does not apply to future deliveries. |
| Can I get it more than once? | No, once per customer. Previous welcome discounts are also checked against your phone number and full delivery address. Create your account with your main email address, without a plus sign. |
Explore your options further
Sources and comparison method
ComFoo's nutritional values come from the Chocolate labels reviewed on 15 October 2026. Jimmy Joy's declarations and both brands' price references were checked on 20 October 2026. Prices, recipes and terms may change.
- ComFoo Original Chocolate and ComFoo Sport Chocolate: product information and current purchase options.
- Jimmy Joy: Vanilla v4.0, macronutrients per 96 g and ingredients and serving instructions for the same recipe.
- Jimmy Joy's EU shop: prices, purchase options and gluten information.
- Product subscription terms and separate Plenny Club terms.
Prices per serving are our own calculations using bag prices and the stated number of servings. We have not carried out a comparative test of taste, satiety or health effects. Product images do not replace the recipe version stated on your packaging.
Your next step
Curious about a Swedish alternative?
Explore Original and Sport. Choose a flavour and check the current ingredients, prices and purchase options.
Explore ComFoo flavours
Find your first ComFoo favourite.
Start with a flavour that appeals to you and give ComFoo a place in your everyday life.
10 € on your first purchase
Personal voucher in your account. Applies to goods, not shipping. See terms.