Huel vs Jimmy Joy vs ComFoo
ComFoo, Huel or Jimmy Joy?
Three brands. Four recipes. Compare one meal at a time.
How do the ingredients and nutrition, serving size and price differ? Here is a clear overview of ComFoo Original, ComFoo Sport, Huel Powder and Plenny Shake.

Try something tasty from ComFoo.
A little help to try something new. Choose a flavour you are curious about and get a personal welcome voucher.
10 € on your first purchase
Personal voucher in your account. Applies to goods, not shipping. See terms.
Huel, Jimmy Joy or a Swedish alternative?
Huel Powder, Jimmy Joy Plenny Shake and ComFoo are meal powders that you mix with water. Here we compare four specific recipes. All list 400 kcal per serving, but the amount of powder, ingredients and pricing options differ.
We compare the Chocolate recipes of ComFoo Original, ComFoo Sport and Huel Powder. For Plenny Shake, we use Vanilla v4.0. The figures apply to these recipes, not to every flavour from each brand.
This article is written by ComFoo. We have compared product labels and dated price information; we have not carried out an independent taste test. See sources and scope.


Three brands, four named recipes
A scoop is not a standard measure across products. Use the declared weight of powder when comparing a meal.
| Product | Flavour and version | Powder per serving | Energy per serving |
|---|---|---|---|
| ComFoo Original | Chocolate | 99 g | 400 kcal |
| ComFoo Sport | Chocolate | 98 g | 400 kcal |
| Huel Powder | Chocolate v3.1 | 100 g | 400 kcal |
| Jimmy Joy Plenny Shake | Vanilla v4.0 | 96 g | 400 kcal |
Huel Black Edition, Plenny Shake Pro and ready-to-drink products are not included. They have their own recipes. Black Edition is included in our separate Huel comparison.
The same energy, a different balance of nutrients
| Nutrient | Original Chocolate · 99 g | Sport Chocolate · 98 g | Huel Chocolate v3.1 · 100 g | Plenny Vanilla v4.0 · 96 g |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Energy | 400 kcal | 400 kcal | 400 kcal | 400 kcal |
| Protein | 21.8 g | 29.3 g | 30 g | 25 g |
| Carbohydrates | 52.2 g | 39.6 g | 37 g | 38 g |
| Fat | 10 g | 10.8 g | 12 g | 15 g |
| Fibre | 6 g | 8.1 g | 9.5 g | 7.6 g |
Among these recipes, Huel Powder has the most protein and fibre per serving. Original has the most carbohydrates and Plenny the most fat. This describes the recipes; it is not an overall ranking of how good the meals are.
ComFoo’s nutrition labels were reviewed on 15 October 2026. The Huel and Jimmy Joy declarations were checked on 20 October 2026. The values are for the powder; milk or another drink adds its own nutrients.
What is the powder made from?
All four recipes contain oats, but their ingredient bases differ. The table summarises some ingredients and labelling information. Read the full list for the flavour you choose.
| Recipe | Selected ingredients | Sweetening | Label information to read |
|---|---|---|---|
| Original Chocolate | Oats, maltodextrin from maize, pea protein, rapeseed oil and cocoa. | Sucralose. | Oats. Original is not ComFoo’s gluten-free range. |
| Sport Chocolate | Gluten-free oats, pea protein, oat protein, fava bean flour, rapeseed oil and cocoa. | Sucralose. | Contains oats. Read all allergen and trace warnings on the packaging. |
| Huel Powder Chocolate v3.1 | Oats, pea protein, flaxseed, tapioca, cocoa and brown rice protein. | Sucralose. | The regular Powder version with oats. The source states that mustard may be present; gluten-free Powder is a separate version. |
| Plenny Shake Vanilla v4.0 | Oats, soya, sunflower oil, rice flour, soya protein isolate, inulin and flaxseed. | Sucralose. | Oats and soya. Check the full allergen information for Vanilla v4.0. |
Taste and texture cannot be inferred from the protein figure. Here, Plenny is also vanilla while the other recipes are chocolate. To compare your own taste experience, choosing the same flavour and following the preparation instructions on each bag is a better starting point.
Curious to try it?
The tables help you compare. Then comes the fun part: finding your own favourite.
10 € on your first purchase
Personal voucher in your account. Applies to goods, not shipping. See terms.
What do ComFoo and Huel cost in Swedish kronor?
These are dated Swedish price references before shipping. One-time purchases and subscriptions are shown separately. The price per serving is the bag price divided by the stated number of servings, rounded to two decimal places.
| Product | Servings per bag | One-off purchase | Subscription |
|---|---|---|---|
| ComFoo Original | 20 | 569 SEK per bag 28.45 SEK per serving | 483.65 SEK per bag 24.18 SEK per serving |
| ComFoo Sport | 16 | 409 SEK per bag 25.56 SEK per serving | 347.65 SEK per bag 21.73 SEK per serving |
| Huel Powder | 17 | 465 SEK per bag 27.35 SEK per serving | 395 SEK per bag 23.24 SEK per serving |
ComFoo: Swedish catalogue prices and a 15% subscription discount, checked on 20 October 2026. Sport is shown here at the promotional price of 409 SEK, with a regular price of 509 SEK. Huel: displayed Swedish online prices on the same date. The number of servings per bag is a separate product detail from the serving weight in the nutrition declaration. Prices and stock can change. Check the current flavour, purchase option, discount and shipping before ordering.
Jimmy Joy’s price is shown in euros
Jimmy Joy’s EU shop lists Plenny Shake in EUR. We keep that currency here. An amount in euros cannot be compared directly with an amount in Swedish kronor.
| Purchase option | Per bag | Per serving |
|---|---|---|
| One-off purchase | 21.90 EUR | 2.19 EUR |
| Subscription with a 20% discount | 17.52 EUR | 1.75 EUR |
The EU shop’s price information was checked on 20 October 2026. The page also shows limited-time promotions. The table is a base-price reference, not a promise of the amount at your checkout. A separate paid membership should not be treated as the same thing as the subscription discount.
To calculate your own price in SEK, use the exchange rate and any currency conversion fee that apply to your purchase. Then add shipping. This comparison does not assume an exchange rate or name an overall cheapest option.
Bag price and order total answer different questions
| What you are comparing | How to calculate it | Also check |
|---|---|---|
| Price for one serving | Bag price after the selected discount ÷ stated number of servings. | The correct flavour, recipe version and purchase option. |
| Your first order | Price for whole bags + shipping and any fees. | Minimum purchase, promotion terms and delivery country. |
| Your next order | The recurring price after the introductory offer ends. | Delivery interval, membership fee and terms for making changes. |
| Purchases in different currencies | Compare the amounts in the same currency at the time of purchase. | Exchange rate, card fee, VAT and shipping. |
A lower price per serving may require a larger purchase. Choose a sensible number of bags for your first order, especially if you have not tried the flavour yet.
Which comparison helps you take the next step?
| Your question | Start here | Keep in mind |
|---|---|---|
| Huel or Jimmy Joy? | Compare Powder Chocolate v3.1 with Plenny Vanilla v4.0 in the nutrition and price tables. | Different flavours and currencies. This is not a taste test. |
| A Swedish alternative? | ComFoo Original and Sport are two different recipes to explore. | Original and Sport have different ingredients and gluten labelling. |
| More protein in the serving being compared? | In this selection, Huel Powder has 30 g and ComFoo Sport has 29.3 g. | Consider the whole recipe, not just the protein figure. |
| Which one will I like? | Choose a flavour you usually enjoy and follow the mixing instructions on the bag. | Ingredients and nutrition values do not determine your taste experience. |
Want to read more about a pair of products? Continue to Huel and ComFoo or Plenny Shake and ComFoo.
Frequently asked questions about Huel, Jimmy Joy and ComFoo
What is the biggest difference between Huel and Jimmy Joy?
Both of the selected recipes provide 400 kcal. Huel Powder Chocolate v3.1 lists 30 g of protein and 9.5 g of fibre in 100 g of powder. Plenny Shake Vanilla v4.0 lists 25 g of protein and 7.6 g of fibre in 96 g. The ingredients and pricing currencies also differ.
Is ComFoo an alternative to both Huel and Plenny Shake?
Yes, if you want to compare meal powders. This comparison includes Original Chocolate and Sport Chocolate, both with declared 400-kcal servings. Choose based on ingredients and nutrition, taste preferences and the purchase option that suits you.
Which option is cheapest?
It depends on the purchase option, number of bags, currency and shipping. The table shows dated base prices in each currency. Then compare your actual order total and the price of your next order.
Do the figures apply to every flavour?
No. The ComFoo and Huel figures refer to the named Chocolate recipes, while Jimmy Joy refers to Vanilla v4.0. Check the flavour and version on your own bag.
Why are Huel Black and Plenny Shake Pro not included?
They are different product ranges. Here we limit the selection to four specific recipes to make the tables easier to follow. Huel Black is covered in the separate Huel article.
Your welcome voucher, simply explained.
| Your question… | How it works |
|---|---|
| What does the discount apply to? | Goods across your whole first order. No minimum order amount. Shipping is not discounted. |
| Can I share it? | No. It is tied to your account, your email address and the currency it is issued in. |
| How do I get it? | Confirm your email address and choose a password using the email link, or continue with your verified Google account. |
| How do I use it? | Select Use under Your vouchers at checkout. Check the total before placing your order. |
| What if I subscribe? | The voucher applies to the first delivery. The regular subscription discount on meals is unaffected. The voucher does not apply to future deliveries. |
| Can I get it more than once? | No, once per customer. Previous welcome discounts are also checked against your phone number and full delivery address. Create your account with your main email address, without a plus sign. |
Explore what matters for your choice
Sources and comparison method
ComFoo’s nutrition values come from the Chocolate labels reviewed on 15 October 2026. The competitors’ named declarations, ingredient information and online prices were checked on 20 October 2026. Shop prices and recipe declarations are separate sources; check the version on the bag you receive.
- ComFoo Original Chocolate and ComFoo Sport Chocolate: product details, flavours and current purchase options.
- Huel Powder v3.1: nutrition declaration, Chocolate section and ingredients for the same recipe.
- Huel’s Swedish shop: bag price and purchase options.
- Jimmy Joy: Vanilla v4.0, macronutrients per 96 g and the ingredient section for Vanilla v4.0.
- Jimmy Joy’s EU shop: Plenny Shake and purchase options.
We calculate the price per serving from the stated bag price and number of servings. No exchange rate has been assumed. We have not compared taste, satiety or climate impact in a product test. Recipes, prices and terms can change.
Your next step
Find a flavour to start with
Explore Original and Sport. Read the ingredients, current prices and purchase options before deciding.
Explore ComFoo’s flavours
Find your first ComFoo favourite.
Start with a flavour that appeals to you and give ComFoo a place in your everyday life.
10 € on your first purchase
Personal voucher in your account. Applies to goods, not shipping. See terms.