Flavour guide
Which meal replacement tastes best in 2026?
Chocolate, vanilla, berries or a neutral base? Compare ComFoo, Huel, Jimmy Joy and Arla based on what you enjoy. See how their ingredients and formats differ, with sources and without invented taste scores.
Read the guide
Which meal replacement could suit your taste?
Do you like chocolate or vanilla? Start by comparing ComFoo, Huel Powder and Jimmy Joy Plenny Shake. To avoid sweeteners, consider ComFoo Sport Neutral and Huel Unflavoured & Unsweetened. If you prefer a ready-made milk-based drink, Arla Food To Go is another option.
This guide is written by ComFoo and compares four selected brands for everyday meals. We reviewed the manufacturers’ product information; we did not carry out a comparative taste test. Suggestions are based on ingredients and your preferences. No product receives a taste score or is named a test winner. See sources and scope.
ComFoo, Huel, Jimmy Joy and Arla: how do the flavours differ?
| Product and format | What the manufacturer states | A starting point for your choice |
|---|---|---|
ComFoo Original / SportPowder | Chocolate in both ranges, berries in Original, and vanilla and apple pie in Sport. The flavoured recipes contain sucralose. Sport Neutral has no flavourings or sweeteners. [1] | For choosing between berry pieces, cocoa and a neutral base. See all eight options in the table below. |
Huel Powder v3.1Powder | Vanilla and Chocolate contain sucralose. The base includes oats, pea protein and flaxseed. Unflavoured & Unsweetened lists no flavourings or sweeteners in its ingredients. [2] | An option to compare with ComFoo if you want to try another oat-based recipe, flavoured or unflavoured. |
Jimmy Joy Plenny Shake v4.0Powder | Vanilla and Chocolate contain oats, soy and sucralose. Strawberry contains freeze-dried strawberry powder. That is not the same as the berry pieces listed for ComFoo Original. [3] | For trying an oat and soy base. Compare vanilla with vanilla, for example, before changing both brand and flavour. |
Arla Protein Food To GoChocolate/caramel · ready-made drink | A milk-based, lactose-free drink with cocoa and flavourings. No added sweeteners according to Arla; it contains isomaltulose. That does not mean sugar-free. Arla recommends serving it chilled and shaken. [4] | For trying chocolate/caramel in a ready-made milk-based drink. You cannot adjust the powder quantity or mixture in the same way here. |
Recipes and formats differ. The table compares product information, not perceived sweetness, smoothness or aftertaste. Check the current packaging for ingredients, allergens and preparation.
Which should I try if I dislike sweeteners?
Want to mix it yourself?
Compare ComFoo Sport Neutral with Huel Powder Unflavoured & Unsweetened v3.1. Both list no flavourings or sweeteners in their ingredients, but their bases differ. Neutral does not mean flavourless. [1] [2]
Want a ready-made drink?
Arla Food To Go Chocolate/caramel has no added sweeteners according to Arla. It contains milk and isomaltulose and is flavoured. It is a different choice from a neutral powder. [4]
The ingredients list helps you choose what to avoid. You need to try the drink yourself to judge its sweetness and whether you enjoy the aftertaste.
If you choose ComFoo: which flavour should you try first?
Start with something you already like:
Berries
Raspberry, Strawberry or Blueberry. All three contain berry pieces.
Vanilla or apple pie
Two Sport flavours. Apple Pie & Vanilla contains apple pieces.
ComFoo’s eight flavours, side by side
| Flavour | Range | A starting point for your choice |
|---|---|---|
| Chocolate | Original | For you if you usually choose chocolate. Contains cocoa. |
| Raspberry | Original | For you if you like raspberries and want a shake with raspberry pieces. |
| Strawberry | Original | For you if you usually choose strawberry. Contains strawberry pieces. |
| Blueberry | Original | For you if you like blueberries. Contains blueberry pieces. |
| Chocolate | Sport | The chocolate option in the Sport range. Contains cocoa. |
| Vanilla | Sport | For you if you prefer vanilla to chocolate, berries or apple pie. |
| Apple Pie & Vanilla | Sport | For you if apple pie and vanilla appeal to you. Contains freeze-dried apple pieces. |
| Neutral | Sport | An option without flavourings or sweeteners, which you can also flavour yourself. |
Open the product page for the full ingredient list and current availability. Always check the ingredients and allergens on the bag you use.
There’s more to it than the flavour name
Want to avoid sweeteners?
- Sport Neutral
- No sweetener listed in the ingredients.
- Flavoured Original and Sport
- Contains the sweetener sucralose.

Do you like pieces?
Raspberry, Strawberry, Blueberry and Apple Pie & Vanilla contain fruit or berry pieces.
Want to avoid added pieces? Look at Chocolate, Sport Vanilla or Sport Neutral.
How sweet will it taste?
The sugar content in the nutrition table alone does not tell you how sweet you will find the drink. Try the prepared shake before deciding.
Same flavour name. Different recipes.
Original Chocolate and Sport Chocolate both contain cocoa. Their base recipes differ.
Original
Oat flour, maltodextrin, pea protein and rapeseed oil.
Sport
Gluten-free oat flour, pea protein isolate, oat protein, fava bean flour and rapeseed oil.
Examples of ingredients in each base recipe. See the full ingredient list on the product page.
Try the texture
How do you like your shake?
Switch to see what more liquid changes.
Same amount of powder
Start with the bag instructions.
Follow the instructions for your flavour the first time.
More liquid dilutes the mix.
The same amount of powder in more liquid makes a more diluted mix. Try a little at a time.
Give your first shake a good start

- Start with the instructions on the bag.Measure powder and liquid according to your product’s instructions.
- Try it without extra flavourings first.Get to know the flavour before adding anything.
- Change one thing at a time.Try a different amount of liquid, for example. Keep track of the amount of powder.
- Try it where you plan to use it.At home, at work or on the go.
When you compare with another shake
Follow each product’s instructions and try it without extra flavourings. Ask the same three questions about both:
- Do I like the flavour?
- Does the sweetness suit me?
- Do I like the texture?
Frequently asked questions about flavour
Which meal replacement tastes best in 2026?
We cannot name an overall taste winner from ingredients lists. For chocolate or vanilla, compare ComFoo, Huel Powder and Jimmy Joy Plenny Shake. To avoid flavourings and sweeteners, start with ComFoo Sport Neutral or Huel Unflavoured & Unsweetened. If you want a ready-made milk-based chocolate/caramel drink, Arla Food To Go is an option. Your own tasting decides which you like best.
Which ComFoo flavour should I choose for the first time?
Choose something you already enjoy: chocolate, berries, vanilla or apple pie. If you want to avoid sweeteners or add your own flavour, Sport Neutral is an option. The table above helps you find the right product.
Is Neutral completely tasteless?
Neutral contains ingredients such as oats, pea protein and fava bean flour, which also contribute flavour. The name does not mean the meal has no flavour of its own. No flavourings or sweeteners are listed in the ingredients.
Can I mix two ComFoo flavours?
You can try combining flavours, such as Chocolate and Raspberry. Keep track of the total amount of powder and follow the preparation instructions. Remember that the nutritional content depends on how much of each product you use.
Can I get my money back if I don't like the flavour?
ComFoo offers a 365-day satisfaction guarantee with no return required. The guarantee can be used once per product category and household and covers the product amount, excluding any shipping costs. Read the full guarantee terms before ordering.
Your favourite starts with a first bag
You don’t need to settle on your ultimate favourite straight away. Start with a flavour you’re curious about.
Explore ComFoo flavours and choose your first bagSources and how we compared
Checked on 19 October 2026. The selection covers three powder brands and one ready-made milk-based meal shake. It is not a review of the entire market. Huel refers to Swedish product information for Powder v3.1, Jimmy Joy to EU information for Plenny Shake v4.0, and Arla to the Swedish 500 ml bottle. Other ranges and markets may have different recipes.
- ComFoo: Original Chocolate, Original Raspberry and Sport Neutral. Ingredients, sweetening and pieces. Other flavours are linked in the ComFoo table.
- Huel: Powder Ingredients v3.1. Ingredients for Vanilla, Chocolate and Unflavoured & Unsweetened.
- Jimmy Joy: Plenny Shake: ingredients section for v4.0. Vanilla, Chocolate and Strawberry. We do not use the page’s older v3 information.
- Arla: Protein Food To Go chocolate/caramel 500 ml. Format, milk base, sweetening and serving advice.
The manufacturers’ information provides sources for the ingredients. It does not prove which brand tastes best. Customer ratings have not been converted into taste scores; they may cover different aspects and do not form a shared blind test.
Terms for your welcome voucher
A personal welcome voucher for your first purchase. Applies to products, not shipping, and is used through your account. You can also create an account without tips and offers. Read the shop's current terms.
Try something tasty from ComFoo.
A little help to try something new. Choose a flavour you are curious about and get a personal welcome voucher.
10 € on your first purchase
Personal voucher in your account. Applies to goods, not shipping. See terms.